https://doi.org/10.24928/2024/0115
Magical vs Methodical: Choosing by Advantages as Antidote to the Planning Fallacy
Eran Haronian1 & Samuel Korb2
1Lecturer, Department of Civil Engineering, Ariel University, Ariel, 40700, Israel, [email protected]2PhD, Graduate of the Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel, [email protected]
Abstract
Cost and schedule overruns are the bane of construction projects, in part due to overly optimistic predictions of project progression. This “optimism bias” is called the planning fallacy, a form of “magical thinking” where planners convince themselves that their project will be different (and better) than others. “Choosing by Advantages” (CBA) is a methodical approach for decision-making. By engaging “slow thinking” at the organizational level, CBA can help counteract the tendency to default to best-case scenarios when selecting among designs and production methods, even in the middle of a project. In this paper, a case study of a Pumped Hydroelectric Energy Storage facility that had to choose between a bottom-up raise boring and a top-down shaft sinking construction method for the vertical shaft connecting the reservoirs is presented. The paper then examines how CBA helped shift the thinking of the project team away from fallacious planning and overcome the sunk-cost fallacy.
Keywords
Choosing by Advantages, Optimism Bias, Planning Fallacy, Risk Management, Monte Carlo
Files
Reference
Haronian, E. & Korb, S. 2024. Magical vs Methodical: Choosing by Advantages as Antidote to the Planning Fallacy, Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean Construction (IGLC 32) , 1099-1110. doi.org/10.24928/2024/0115
Download: BibTeX | RIS Format
Founded in 1993, the IGLC is an international network of researchers from practice and academia in architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) who feel that the practice, education, and research of the AEC industry have to be radically renewed in order to respond to the global challenges ahead.
2015 © All Rights Reserved.