TY - CONF TI - Comparing Three Methods in the Tendering Procedure to Select the Project Team C1 - Perth, Australia C3 - 23rd Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean Construction SP - 267 EP - 276 PY - 2015 AU - Schöttle, Annett AU - Arroyo, Paz AU - Bade, Michael AD - 1 PhD Candidate. Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Institute for Technol. and Mgmt. in Construction (TMB), Am Fasanengarten, Geb. 50.31, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany.Phone +49 721608-42168, annett.schoettle@kit.edu. Supervisor: Prof. Dr.-Ing. Fritz Gehbauer, M.S. AD - Assistant Professor.Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Chile.Phone +5622354-4244, parroyo@ing.puc.cl. AD - Associate Vice Chancellor. Capital Programs & Campus Architect, University of California San Francisco (UCSF), 654 Minnesota Street, San Francisco CA 94143, USA. +1 415502-6460, michael.bade@ucsf.edu. ED - Seppänen, Olli ED - González, Vicente A. ED - Arroyo, Paz AB - Normally, the selection of a project team is based on Weighting Rating Calculating (WRC) and often relies on only one factor; the cost factor. WRC is a method that allows for assessing multiple factors easily but the bidders’ differences may not be highlighted, since factors are weighted independently of the attributes. A more recent concept, which is based on WRC, is Best Value Selection (BVS). BVS is a method where the best value score is calculated as the bid price divided by the qualification score. Choosing By Advantage (CBA) is a multiple-criteria decision-making method based on advantages of alternatives. Advantages are compared in order to decide the importance of them. We argue that CBA provides further benefits for helping public clients to differentiate between bidders. A case was constructed, based on the tendering procedure of the project Mission Hall, to exemplify the differences of the three methods for bidder selection in the context of public tendering requirements. This paper presents the analysis and discusses the results of the simulated case. KW - Best value selection KW - choosing by advantage KW - weighting rating calculating KW - selection KW - tendering procedure KW - project team PB - T2 - 23rd Annual Conference of the International Group for Lean Construction DA - 2015/07/29 CY - Perth, Australia L1 - http://iglc.net/Papers/Details/1180/pdf L2 - http://iglc.net/Papers/Details/1180 N1 - Export Date: 28 March 2024 DB - IGLC.net DP - IGLC LA - English ER -